Put every Premier League game in your calendar, with the UK TV channel
What the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents panel has ruled this season, round by round and club by club, quoted with the votes and the publication date. This is the only place a verdict on whether a decision was right appears on this site, because the panel is the only body that publishes one.
Match Round 10, published 18 November 2026: 27 referee KMIs in Match Round 10, 78 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct and the one VAR overturn supported; 223 KMIs across the season to date, 85 per cent of on-field decisions and 97 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct.
Votes are written as the Premier League prints them. The first figure is the number of panellists who judged the decision correct and the second is the number who judged it incorrect.
Panel-reviewed incidents by club
Incidents carried on this page from each club’s games, with how many the panel found incorrect on the field, how many involved a VAR overturn, and how many VAR outcomes it found incorrect. Read alongside the club’s VAR overturns.
Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
| Club | Incidents here | On-field found incorrect | VAR overturns reviewed | VAR outcome found incorrect |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ipswich Town | 15 | 7 | 4 | 1 |
| Manchester United | 14 | 5 | 4 | 1 |
| Manchester City | 12 | 6 | 5 | 1 |
| Liverpool | 11 | 7 | 4 | 1 |
| Arsenal | 10 | 7 | 2 | 3 |
| Aston Villa | 10 | 9 | 4 | 1 |
| Chelsea | 10 | 7 | 4 | 0 |
| Sunderland | 10 | 5 | 4 | 0 |
| Tottenham | 10 | 5 | 3 | 0 |
| Brentford | 9 | 4 | 4 | 0 |
| Brighton | 9 | 3 | 3 | 0 |
| Hull City | 9 | 3 | 1 | 2 |
| Crystal Palace | 8 | 6 | 4 | 0 |
| Fulham | 8 | 2 | 2 | 0 |
| Coventry City | 6 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
| Leeds United | 6 | 3 | 2 | 0 |
| Newcastle United | 6 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
| Nottingham Forest | 6 | 5 | 3 | 0 |
| Bournemouth | 5 | 4 | 2 | 0 |
| Everton | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
Match Round 1, published 2 September 2026
21 referee KMIs in Match Round 1; 90 per cent of on-field decisions and 100 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct; two VAR overturns, both supported. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Brighton v Villa, Sun 23 Aug, 37:20. Sending off not given. Actions of Gomes (AVL) on Rutter (BHA). On-field decision: incorrect, violent conduct by Gomes (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The VAR intervention to award a red card for violent conduct was unanimously supported. Gomes kicked out at Rutter after the ball had gone.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 1, published by the Premier League on 2 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brighton v Villa, Sun 23 Aug, 78:53. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by McGinn (AVL) on Osman (BHA). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by McGinn (1:4); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (3:2). The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The panel were split, 4:1, with the majority feeling that a penalty should have been awarded on-field. McGinn steps into challenge Osman and makes contact without playing the ball. Whilst the majority of the panel preferred the outcome to be a penalty, with the high threshold for VAR intervention, the majority, 3:2, felt that it was not a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 1, published by the Premier League on 2 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man City v Bournemouth, Sun 23 Aug, 90:00+00:30. Goal not awarded. Gvardiol (MCI) in an offside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Gvardiol onside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was Jarred Gillett.
“The panel supported the VAR intervention to award the goal with Gvardiol judged to be factually onside.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 1, published by the Premier League on 2 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Newcastle v Liverpool, Sun 23 Aug, 90:00+05:09. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Hall (NEW) on Muñoz (LIV). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Stuart Attwell.
“The panel unanimously supported the Referee’s call of a penalty. Hall stepped across Munoz making contact with the attacker and not with the ball.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 1, published by the Premier League on 2 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brentford v Spurs, Sat 22 Aug, 46:56. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Senesi (TOT) on Collins (BRE). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Michael Oliver.
“The panel unanimously supported the Referee’s call of no penalty, understanding that there is a slight pull on Collins’ shirt, but judging that Collins had initially instigated the contact with Senesi before going to ground.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 1, published by the Premier League on 2 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Fulham v Chelsea, Mon 24 Aug, 18:52. Penalty not awarded. Handball appeal against Robinson (FUL). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was John Brooks.
“The Referee’s call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Robinson was supported, 4:1. The ball comes off his head before making contact with his arm as he is stooping to clear. One panellist felt that the movement of Robinson’s right arm was deliberate and a penalty should have been awarded.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 1, published by the Premier League on 2 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 2, published 9 September 2026
56 referee KMIs across the season to date after Match Round 2; 84 per cent of on-field decisions and 96 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Liverpool v Forest, Sat 29 Aug, 31:50. Goal awarded. Frimpong (LIV) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Frimpong offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual offside (5:0). The referee was Sam Barrott.
“The VAR overturn to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Frimpong was supported. When the ball was played, by Wirtz, Frimpong was in an offside position and then plays the ball himself. Whilst the pass makes contact with a defender this is not a ‘controlled action’.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 2, published by the Premier League on 9 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Liverpool v Forest, Sat 29 Aug, 67:43. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Alisson (LIV) on Williams (NFO). On-field decision: incorrect, no foul by Alisson (2:3); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was Sam Barrott.
“The panel felt that the referee’s call of a penalty was incorrect on-field, 3:2. The contact from Alisson was inevitable as a consequence of his momentum in attempting to save the ball; the contact made was not reckless and below the threshold for a penalty. However, the non-intervention by the VAR was unanimously supported on the basis that it was not a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 2, published by the Premier League on 9 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Leeds v Brentford, Sun 30 Aug, 65:37. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Bogle (LDS) on Schade (BRE). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Bogle (1:4); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (3:2). The referee was Tony Harrington.
“The panel felt that a penalty should have been awarded for a foul by Bogle on Schade, 4:1. There was foot on foot contact instigated by Bogle with enough contact for a penalty kick. However, given the high threshold for VAR intervention, the panel felt the referee’s call should remain on-field as it wasn’t a clear and obvious error, 3:2.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 2, published by the Premier League on 9 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Ipswich, Sun 30 Aug, 55:55. Goal awarded. Handball appeal against Maguire (MUN). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Craig Pawson.
“Maguire’s arms are within his bodyline meaning that the contact with his right arm was accidental and not a punishable handball offence given that Maguire was not the goal scorer. The shot was clearly off target and then deflected in via the defender for a clear own goal. The panel supported the referee’s call to award the goal, 4:1, with one panellist considering the handball to be deliberate.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 2, published by the Premier League on 9 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Ipswich, Sun 30 Aug, 58:36. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Greaves (IPS) on Cunha (MUN). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Craig Pawson.
“The on-field call of a penalty was unanimously supported. A clear foul by Greaves on Cunha as he ran through on goal with a correct yellow card for DOGSO as it was a genuine challenge for the ball.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 2, published by the Premier League on 9 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Villa v Arsenal, Mon 31 Aug, 53:43. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Maatsen (AVL) on Saka (ARS). On-field decision: incorrect, factually outside the area (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Jarred Gillett.
“The VAR intervention to award a free kick instead of a penalty was unanimously supported with the foul occurring just outside the area.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 2, published by the Premier League on 9 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Villa v Arsenal, Mon 31 Aug, 90:00+07:27. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Maatsen (AVL) on Guimaraes (ARS). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Maatsen (0:5); no VAR intervention, which the panel found incorrect, clear and obvious error (0:5). The referee was Jarred Gillett.
“The panel felt that a penalty should have been awarded on-field for Maatsen’s reckless challenge on Guimaraes. Clear contact was made on the attacker’s standing leg and Maatsen made no contact with the ball. They also felt that VAR should have intervened as the non-penalty award was a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 2, published by the Premier League on 9 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Villa v Arsenal, Mon 31 Aug, 90:00+07:28. Second caution not given. Challenge by Maatsen (AVL) on Guimaraes (ARS). On-field decision: incorrect (0:5); VAR not applicable. The referee was Jarred Gillett.
“The panel felt that the challenge was reckless and therefore a second caution should have been awarded.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 2, published by the Premier League on 9 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 3, published 16 September 2026
18 referee KMIs in Match Round 3, 94 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct; 60 KMIs across the season to date, 87 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Ipswich v Liverpool, Fri 4 Sept, 67:07. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Davis (IPS) on Szoboszlai (LIV), offside decision. On-field decision: incorrect (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual offside (5:0). The referee was Darren England.
“There was a clear offside offence in the attacking phase which negated any potential penalty award. The on field offside decision was incorrect and the VAR intervention was correct to identify this as part of the potential penalty review. The panel would have expected a penalty to be awarded if there was no offside offence beforehand.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 3, published by the Premier League on 16 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brentford v Sunderland, Sat 5 Sept, 06:22. Goal awarded. Danso (SUN) in an offside position, line of vision. On-field decision: incorrect, Danso offside and impacting (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Tom Bramall.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for a line of vision offside offence was supported. Danso was in a clear offside position, directly in the line of vision of the goalkeeper and impacted his ability to make a save.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 3, published by the Premier League on 16 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brentford v Sunderland, Sat 5 Sept, 79:02. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Lewis-Potter (BRE) on Isidor (SUN). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Tom Bramall.
“Lewis-Potter was not looking at the ball and makes a clear and sustained holding action that impacts Isidor’s ability to progress towards the ball. The panel supported the referee’s call of penalty for a holding offence, 4:1.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 3, published by the Premier League on 16 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Forest v Spurs, Sat 5 Sept, 65:00. Goal awarded. Handball appeal against Williams (NFO). On-field decision: incorrect, factual handball (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Craig Pawson.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for an accidental handball offence by Williams was supported. The ball factually makes contact with Williams on the arm before going directly into the goal.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 3, published by the Premier League on 16 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Fulham v Palace, Sat 5 Sept, 13:25. Goal awarded. Kamada (CRY) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Kamada offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Sam Barrott.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Kamada was supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 3, published by the Premier League on 16 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Arsenal v Chelsea, Sun 6 Sept, 11:11. Goal awarded. Konsa (ARS) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Konsa offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Chris Kavanagh.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Konsa was supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 3, published by the Premier League on 16 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Ipswich v Liverpool, Fri 4 Sept, 44:56. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Fatawu (IPS) on Gakpo (LIV). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Darren England.
“An unusual situation where some contact is made by Fatawu on Gakpo after the ball is laid off. The panel was split, 4:1, with the majority feeling that the contact was below the high threshold for a foul and they unanimously felt that this was not a clear and obvious error for VAR intervention.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 3, published by the Premier League on 16 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 4, published 23 September 2026
19 referee KMIs in Match Round 4, 95 per cent of on-field decisions and 100 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct; 79 KMIs across the season to date, 89 per cent of on-field decisions and 97 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Man City, Sun 13 Sept, 59:25. Goal not awarded. Haaland (MCI) in an onside position, Fernandez (MCI) in an offside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Fernandez impacting opponent (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found incorrect, clear and obvious error (0:5). The referee was Michael Oliver.
“The panel unanimously felt that the VAR intervention to award the goal was incorrect. Fernandez is in an offside position, attempts to play the ball that is close to him, and impacts the ability of the defender and the goalkeeper to play the ball in the process. A VAR review should have been recommended for a missed subjective offside in the attacking possession phase.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Man City, Sun 13 Sept, 22:15. Sending off given. Actions of Foden (MCI) on Fernandes (MUN). On-field decision: correct (3:2); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Michael Oliver.
“The panel supported the referee’s call of a red card, 3:2, for the violent conduct following the retaliatory action of Foden pushing his legs into the midriff of Bruno. Two panellists felt that the action lacked the force to reach the threshold for a red card, and would have preferred a yellow card.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Man City, Sun 13 Sept, 22:15. Sending off not given. Actions of Fernandes (MUN) on Foden (MCI). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Michael Oliver.
“The panel unanimously supported the referee’s call of no red card for a potential violent conduct action by Bruno, but all felt that a yellow card would have been the appropriate punishment.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Sunderland v Arsenal, Sat 12 Sept, 53:28. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Konsa (ARS) on Ballard (SUN). On-field decision: incorrect (0:5); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (3:2). The referee was John Brooks.
“The panel unanimously felt that the referee’s call of a penalty for a holding offence was incorrect. Although it was a very untidy challenge in which Konsa initially had arms around Ballard, Ballard engages in a holding action which pulls Konsa onto him so they both fall to the floor. The non-VAR intervention was supported, 3:2, with the majority considering that the on-field decision was not a clear and obvious error, given the combined actions from both players.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Sunderland v Arsenal, Sat 12 Sept, 90:00+05:16. Penalty awarded and second caution given. Challenge by Mandava (SUN) on Saka (ARS). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was John Brooks.
“The on-field award of a penalty was supported with an initial holding action by Reinildo followed by a genuine attempt to challenge for the ball, tripping Saka inside the penalty area. The second caution dismissal for Reinildo was supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Coventry v Brighton, Sun 13 Sept, 51:49. Sending off given. Challenge by Awoniyi (COV) on De Cuyper (BHA). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Tony Harrington.
“The on-field call of a red card for violent conduct against Awoniyi was supported. Awoniyi is not challenging for the ball and makes a striking action with his arm that makes contact with the face of his opponent.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Palace v Ipswich, Sat 12 Sept, 33:35. Sending off given. Challenge by Disasi (CRY) on Clarke (IPS). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Chris Kavanagh.
“The referee’s call of a red card for serious foul play was supported. The speed at which Disasi enters the challenge and the high point of contact with studs were the main factors in supporting this decision.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Liverpool v Fulham, Sat 12 Sept, 10:29. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Alisson (LIV) on King (FUL). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Tom Bramall.
“The panel supported the referee’s call of no penalty, 4:1. Alisson committed to a challenge which was then hurdled by King following completion of his action to pass the ball; so the lack of contact made it difficult to award a penalty.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Leeds v Newcastle, Mon 14 Sept, 63:58. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Muharemovic (LDS) on Barnes (NEW). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Michael Salisbury.
“The referee’s call of no penalty for a potential foul by Muharemovic on Barnes was supported, 4:1, with the contact not meeting the threshold for a foul.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 4, published by the Premier League on 23 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 5, published 30 September 2026
17 referee KMIs in Match Round 5, 88 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct and all five VAR overturns supported; 96 KMIs across the season to date, 89 per cent of on-field decisions and 98 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Everton v Ipswich, Sat 19 Sept, 57:19. Goal awarded. Johnson (EVE) in an offside position, not interfering with opponent. On-field decision: incorrect, offside offence by Johnson (2:3); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (3:2). The referee was Stuart Attwell.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for interfering with an opponent by Johnson was supported, 3:2. Johnson was clearly in an offside position, in very close proximity to the goalkeeper and makes a movement, impacting the goalkeeper’s ability to set and move to the ball. Two panellists felt that Johnson’s position and actions did not impact goalkeeper Walton.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Forest v Coventry, Sat 19 Sept, 85:56. Goal awarded. Challenge by Jesus (NFO) on Yirenkyi (COV). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Jesus (1:4); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (4:1). The referee was Jarred Gillett.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for a foul by Jesus was supported, 4:1. The attacker carelessly stepped on the heel of Yirenkyi which was impactful in the lead up to the goal.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Spurs v Villa, Sat 19 Sept, 59:18. Goal awarded. Robertson (TOT) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Robertson offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual offside (5:0). The referee was Sam Barrott.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Robertson was supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Newcastle v Hull, Sat 19 Sept, 44:41. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Thomas (HUL) on Murphy (NEW). On-field decision: correct (3:2); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Tony Harrington.
“The on-field call of a penalty was supported, 3:2. Thomas reached out and made contact with the foot of Murphy. Two panellists felt the action was not impactful and below the threshold for a penalty. The non-VAR intervention was supported, 5:0.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brighton v Arsenal, Sat 19 Sept, 52:15. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Calafiori (ARS) on Kadioglu (BHA). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Darren England.
“The referee’s call of no penalty was supported, with the contact by Calafiori below the threshold for a penalty.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brighton v Arsenal, Sat 19 Sept, 56:21. Goal awarded. Struijk (BHA) in an offside position, not interfering with opponent. On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Darren England.
“The on-field decision to award the goal, due to there being no offside offence, was supported. Struijk was behind the defender and behind the goalkeeper, therefore not impacting either opponent.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man City v Sunderland, Sun 20 Sept, 42:41. Goal awarded. Handball appeal against Guéhi (MCI). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Rob Jones.
“The referee’s call to award the goal was supported, 4:1. The ball did strike the arm of Guehi but it was not deliberate and he was not the goalscorer.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man City v Sunderland, Sun 20 Sept, 54:33. Penalty not awarded. Handball appeal against Anderson (MCI). On-field decision: correct (3:2); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Rob Jones.
“The referee’s call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Anderson was supported, 3:2. Both players were engaged and the ball was bouncing at close proximity after deflecting off Le Fee. Two panellists felt that there was a deliberate secondary movement of the arm from Anderson that was a handball offence.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man City v Sunderland, Sun 20 Sept, 80:58. Goal not awarded. Gvardiol (MCI) in an offside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Gvardiol onside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual onside (5:0). The referee was Rob Jones.
“The VAR intervention to award the goal with Gvardiol in an onside position was supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Leeds v Palace, Sun 20 Sept, 51:15. Goal awarded. Khalaili (CRY) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Khalaili offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual offside (5:0). The referee was Adam Herczeg.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Khalaili was supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 5, published by the Premier League on 30 September 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 6, published 21 October 2026
18 referee KMIs in Match Round 6, 89 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct and both VAR overturns supported; 114 KMIs across the season to date, 89 per cent of on-field decisions and 98 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Sunderland v Brighton, Sat 10 Oct, 56:50. DOGSO not given. Challenge by Struijk (BHA) on Isidor (SUN). On-field decision: incorrect, DOGSO by Struijk (2:3); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (3:2). The referee was Tom Bramall.
“The defender makes a cynical foul clearly impacting the attacker’s ability to gain possession of the ball which should have been penalised by the referee. The on-field no DOGSO red card decision was deemed incorrect, 3:2. Two panellists supported the on-field no DOGSO call as they deemed it unlikely that Isidor would get possession of the ball. The VAR outcome was supported 3:2. Despite supporting the final outcome, two panellists felt the intervention was incorrect due to the subjectivity of whether Isidor would gain possession.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 6, published by the Premier League on 21 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Hull v Everton, Sun 11 Oct, 33:21. Goal awarded. Johnson (EVE) in an onside position, no immediate challenge. On-field decision: incorrect (1:4); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Michael Salisbury.
“The on-field decision was deemed incorrect and the VAR intervention was supported, 4:1. Johnson is in an offside position when Armstrong shoots at goal, and remains active following the save by the defender. Following the save, Johnson makes an immediate challenge on the defender, limiting the defender’s options to clear the ball. One panellist deemed the on-field decision correct and the VAR intervention incorrect as they felt the defender made a deliberate action to clear the ball before Johnson impacts.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 6, published by the Premier League on 21 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Palace v Forest, Sun 11 Oct, 45:00+03:05. Goal awarded. Handball appeal against Khalaili (CRY). On-field decision: incorrect, handball by Khalaili (2:3); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The panel noted the difficulty in this decision due to the readily available footage. The referee’s call to award the goal was deemed incorrect 3:2 on the basis that on the balance of probability the ball is likely to have come into contact with Khalaili’s arm. The panel all supported the VAR’s decision to not intervene on the basis that the footage readily available to the VAR doesn’t show conclusive evidence of a handball.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 6, published by the Premier League on 21 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Palace v Forest, Sun 11 Oct, 90:00+03:25. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Muñoz (NFO) on Sarr (CRY). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The referee’s call of no penalty was supported, 4:1, as the majority deemed both players coming together and contact not meeting the threshold to award a penalty. One panellist deemed the on-field decision incorrect for a foul on Sarr but supported no VAR intervention as the decision should remain referee’s call.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 6, published by the Premier League on 21 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Ipswich v Fulham, Sat 10 Oct, 74:35. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Sessegnon (FUL) on Daizen (IPS). On-field decision: correct (3:2); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Lewis Smith.
“The referee’s call of no penalty was supported, 3:2. The majority felt the contact from Sessegnon was just below the threshold to award a penalty. Two panellists deemed the on-field decision incorrect on the basis that Daizen gets in front of the defender who then makes contact with his legs. The VAR decision to not intervene was deemed correct, 4:1.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 6, published by the Premier League on 21 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Spurs, Sat 10 Oct, 76:33. Sending off given. Actions of Bentancur (TOT) on Shaw (MUN). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Stuart Attwell.
“The on-field red card decision was supported. The actions of Bentancur meet the threshold for violent conduct.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 6, published by the Premier League on 21 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Spurs, Sat 10 Oct, 76:33. Sending off not given. Actions of Shaw (MUN) on Bentancur (TOT). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Stuart Attwell.
“The on-field no red card decision was supported, 4:1. Shaw’s actions are aggressive but don’t meet the threshold for violent conduct. One panellist felt that Shaw’s push was with excessive force so deemed the on-field decision incorrect and would have supported a VAR intervention to recommend a red card.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 6, published by the Premier League on 21 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Liverpool v Man City, Sun 11 Oct, 61:34. Second caution given. Challenge by Gravenberch (LIV) on Doku (MCI). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Chris Kavanagh.
“The on-field second caution dismissal was deemed correct, 4:1. The second yellow card decision was supported unanimously for stopping a promising attack. However, one panellist deemed the on-field decision incorrect on the basis that the first caution decision for a foul on Anderson was not a yellow card offence. All panellists supported the VAR’s decision on the basis that they can only judge the second caution decision.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 6, published by the Premier League on 21 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 7, published 28 October 2026
24 referee KMIs in Match Round 7, 88 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct and all four VAR overturns supported; 138 KMIs across the season to date, 88 per cent of on-field decisions and 99 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Newcastle v Villa, Sat 17 Oct, 17:35. Sending off not given. Challenge by Botman (NEW) on Jackson (AVL). On-field decision: incorrect, serious foul play by Botman (1:4); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (3:2). The referee was Jarred Gillett.
“This was a split decision with the majority of the panel feeling that a red card for serious foul play should have been awarded, 4:1. Botman was out of control, lunging at speed, making forceful contact with Jackson despite his leading leg missing the Villa attacker. The non-VAR intervention was supported, 3:2, on the basis it was not a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 7, published by the Premier League on 28 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man City v Ipswich, Sat 17 Oct, 84:35. Goal awarded. Fernandez (MCI) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Fernandez offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual offside (5:0). The referee was Farai Hallam.
“The VAR overturn to disallow the goal for a factual offside decision was supported as correct.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 7, published by the Premier League on 28 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man City v Ipswich, Sat 17 Oct, 86:53. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Guéhi (MCI) on Fatawu (IPS). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Guehi (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was Farai Hallam.
“The VAR overturn to award a penalty for a foul by Guehi on Fatawu was supported. The Ipswich attacker got a touch on the ball to take it away from the City defender before being clearly fouled.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 7, published by the Premier League on 28 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brentford v Liverpool, Sat 17 Oct, 40:06. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Ouattara (BRE) on MacAllister (LIV). On-field decision: incorrect, no foul by Ouattara (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was John Brooks.
“The VAR intervention to overturn the on-field penalty decision was supported. Ouattara got a touch on the ball before making contact with the Liverpool attacker.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 7, published by the Premier League on 28 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brentford v Liverpool, Sat 17 Oct, 45:00+03:59. Sending off not given. Actions of Yarmolyuk (BRE) on Jacquet (LIV). On-field decision: incorrect, violent conduct by Yarmolyuk (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was John Brooks.
“The VAR overturn to issue a red card for violent conduct against Yarmolyuk was unanimously supported with a clear movement of the head making contact with Jacquet.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 7, published by the Premier League on 28 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Fulham v Hull, Sat 17 Oct, 90:00+03:00. Sending off given. Challenge by Sessegnon (FUL) on Vaz (HUL). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Chris Kavanagh.
“The referee’s call of a red card for serious foul play was unanimously supported. Sessegnon made high, full and forceful contact on Vaz’s Achilles, endangering his safety.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 7, published by the Premier League on 28 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Leeds v Man Utd, Sun 18 Oct, 18:23. Sending off not given. Challenge by Gudmundsson (LDS) on Santos (MUN). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Darren England.
“The on-field call of a yellow card was supported for a reckless challenge by Gudmundsson. Contact was made on Santos’ ankle as he looked to change direction, but with low force and below the threshold for serious foul play.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 7, published by the Premier League on 28 October 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 8, published 4 November 2026
24 referee KMIs in Match Round 8, 88 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct and the one VAR overturn supported; 162 KMIs across the season to date, 88 per cent of on-field decisions and 99 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Villa v Man City, Sat 24 Oct, 29:23. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Anderson (MCI) on Manzambi (AVL). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Anderson (2:3); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (3:2). The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The on-field no penalty call was deemed incorrect, 3:2. Anderson makes no attempt to win the ball and makes his body bigger by moving across to block Manzambi. The panel supported the VAR’s decision to not intervene, 3:2, as they felt the subjectivity of the decision meant it should remain referee’s call. Two panellists would have supported an intervention for a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 8, published by the Premier League on 4 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Coventry v Fulham, Sat 24 Oct, 45:00+00:42. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Thomas-Asante (COV) on Bassey (FUL). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Adam Herczeg.
“The outcome of no penalty was supported by the panel. There is a clear and impactful holding action by Bassey before the ball is in play from the corner kick, followed by a subsequent holding action by Thomas-Asante when the ball is in play. The panel felt the VAR correctly identified both actions. In this situation, as Bassey commits an offence before the ball is in play and the holding action of Thomas-Asante met the threshold for a penalty to be awarded, the VAR should recommend an on-field review to allow the referee to consider both holding actions and reach the correct outcome of retaken corner.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 8, published by the Premier League on 4 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Chelsea v Spurs, Sat 24 Oct, 69:37. Sending off not given. Actions of Palmer (CHE) on Fernandes (TOT). On-field decision: incorrect, violent conduct by Palmer (2:3); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was Chris Kavanagh.
“The on-field no red card decision was deemed incorrect, 3:2. The majority felt that Palmer’s action on Fernandes was clear contact to the head as well as unnecessary, dangerous and made with excessive force. Two panellists supported the on-field call as they viewed the action as aggressive with no excessive force. All panellists supported the VAR’s decision to not intervene and support the referee’s call given that a yellow card was awarded on-field.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 8, published by the Premier League on 4 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Chelsea v Spurs, Sat 24 Oct, 79:31. Second caution given. Challenge by Palmer (CHE) on Gallagher (TOT). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Chris Kavanagh.
“The on-field second yellow card decision was supported, 4:1. The challenge from Palmer is reckless and avoidable. One panellist deemed this incorrect for a careless foul rather than reckless but supported the VAR not intervening as this decision should remain referee’s call.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 8, published by the Premier League on 4 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Chelsea v Spurs, Sat 24 Oct, 84:26. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Caicedo (CHE) on Solanke (TOT). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Caicedo (2:3); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (3:2). The referee was Chris Kavanagh.
“The on-field no penalty call was deemed incorrect, 3:2. The majority felt Caicedo was persistently holding Solanke whilst facing away from the ball and impacting the ability of the opponent to progress. Two panellists supported the on-field call as they felt both players are engaging and Caicedo is twisting to look at the ball. The VAR decision to not intervene was supported, 3:2.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 8, published by the Premier League on 4 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Hull v Brentford, Sun 25 Oct, 60:20. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Sangare (BRE) on Belloumi (HUL). On-field decision: correct (3:2); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Rob Jones.
“The on-field no penalty call was supported, 3:2. The majority felt that the contact from Sangare did not meet the threshold to award a penalty kick and that Belloumi stepped across Sangare. Two panellists deemed the on-field decision incorrect as Sangare’s contact is careless and clumsy as Belloumi is in possession of the ball. All panellists supported the no VAR intervention as this challenge should remain referee’s call on-field.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 8, published by the Premier League on 4 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Bournemouth, Sun 25 Oct, 37:40. Goal awarded. Hill (BOU) in an offside position, not interfering. On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Jarred Gillett.
“The on-field decision to award the goal was supported, 4:1. Hill is in an offside position but not impacting the defender’s ability to play the ball. One panellist deemed the on-field decision incorrect and would have supported a VAR intervention as Hill impacts Santos’ run to defend the ball.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 8, published by the Premier League on 4 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Palace v Newcastle, Sun 25 Oct, 51:08. Goal awarded. Willock (NEW) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Willock offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual offside (5:0). The referee was Paul Tierney.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal was supported as Willock was in an offside position.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 8, published by the Premier League on 4 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 9, published 11 November 2026
34 referee KMIs in Match Round 9, 76 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct and all seven VAR overturns supported; 196 KMIs across the season to date, 86 per cent of on-field decisions and 97 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Chelsea v Man Utd, Sat 31 Oct, 33:25. Goal awarded. Cunha (MUN) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Cunha offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual offside (5:0). The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The VAR overturn to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Cunha was supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Chelsea v Man Utd, Sat 31 Oct, 59:58. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Martinez (MUN) on Fofana (CHE). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Martinez (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The VAR overturn to award a penalty for a reckless foul by Martinez on Fofana was supported unanimously. The VAR intervened because of a clearly missed penalty and whilst reviewing the footage the VAR concluded that the foul was reckless.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Chelsea v Man Utd, Sat 31 Oct, 59:58. Second caution not given. Challenge by Martinez (MUN) on Fofana (CHE). On-field decision: incorrect (0:5); VAR not applicable. The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The referee’s decision to award a second caution for the reckless challenge by Martinez after the VAR review was also unanimously supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Chelsea v Man Utd, Sat 31 Oct, 70:34. Goal awarded. Estevao (CHE) in an onside position. On-field decision: incorrect, Estevao offside (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual offside (5:0). The referee was Peter Bankes.
“The VAR overturn to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Estevao was supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Bournemouth v Leeds, Sat 31 Oct, 10:53. Goal awarded. Handball appeal against Calvert-Lewin (LDS). On-field decision: incorrect, handball by Calvert-Lewin (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, factual handball (5:0). The referee was Michael Salisbury.
“The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for a handball offence by Calvert-Lewin was supported. The ball struck the attacker’s arm before going directly into the goal.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Coventry v Sunderland, Sat 31 Oct, 61:59. Penalty not awarded. Handball appeal against Pinnock (COV). On-field decision: incorrect, handball by Pinnock (2:3); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (3:2). The referee was Simon Hooper.
“Pinnock’s arm was up at shoulder level and extended outwards making his body unjustifiably bigger and blocking a shot towards goal. The panel supported the referee’s call of penalty for a handball offence, 3:2. Two panellists felt that Pinnock’s arm placement was expected given his blocking action and the shot was not on target.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man City v Brighton, Sat 31 Oct, 45:00+01:08. Penalty not awarded. Handball appeal against Dunk (BHA). On-field decision: correct (3:2); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (3:2). The referee was Craig Pawson.
“The no penalty decision for a potential handball offence against Dunk was supported, 3:2. The ball struck Dunk on the thigh/arm before hitting his opposite arm, with his arms down by his side. Two panellists felt that Dunk had enough time to reposition his arms given the distance the ball travelled and considered this a punishable handball.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Hull v Ipswich, Sat 31 Oct, 17:31. Penalty not awarded. Handball appeal against Egan (HUL). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Thomas Kirk.
“The no penalty decision for a potential handball offence against Egan was supported, 4:1.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Hull v Ipswich, Sat 31 Oct, 17:31. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Mendy (HUL) on O’Shea (IPS). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Mendy (1:4); no VAR intervention, which the panel found incorrect, clear and obvious error (1:4). The referee was Thomas Kirk.
“This was a split decision, 4:1, with the majority feeling that there was a clear sustained holding offence by Mendy and a penalty should have been awarded. One panellist considered that the actions of O’Shea and Florentino should have been taken into account, meaning no penalty.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Hull v Ipswich, Sat 31 Oct, 20:19. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Mendy (HUL) on O’Shea (IPS). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Thomas Kirk.
“The outcome of no penalty was supported by the panel. There is a clear and impactful holding action by O’Shea before the ball is in play from the corner kick, followed by a clear block by Florentino after the ball is in play, both prior to the holding action by Mendy. In this situation O’Shea commits an offence before the ball is in play, and Florentino makes a clear block when the ball is in play before the holding action by Mendy. As the holding action of Mendy meets the threshold for a clear and obvious error, a VAR intervention to recommend an on-field review should have occurred to allow the referee to consider all of the events in chronological order to reach the outcome of no penalty and a retaken corner.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Hull v Ipswich, Sat 31 Oct, 53:00. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Mendy (HUL) on Emersonn (IPS). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Thomas Kirk.
“The panel supported the referee’s call of no penalty on the basis that the contact from the challenge by Mendy was just outside the area, 4:1.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Spurs v Palace, Sat 31 Oct, 10:26. Sending off not given. Challenge by Mateta (CRY) on Van de Ven (TOT). On-field decision: incorrect, serious foul play by Mateta (1:4); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (4:1). The referee was Michael Oliver.
“The VAR intervention to issue a red card for serious foul play was supported, 4:1. The challenge from Mateta was late, with a high degree of force/intensity and makes contact with the Achillies. One panellist felt it wasn’t a clear and obvious error for intervention and supported the on-field call of a yellow card.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Villa v Fulham, Sat 31 Oct, 11:45. Penalty not awarded. Handball appeal against Berge (FUL). On-field decision: incorrect, handball by Berge (0:5); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct, clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was Sam Barrott.
“The VAR intervention to award a penalty for a handball offence by Berge was supported unanimously with the ball hitting the arm that was in an unjustifiable position above his head.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Liverpool v Arsenal, Sun 1 Nov, 19:57. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Timber (ARS) on Isak (LIV). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Timber (1:4); no VAR intervention, which the panel found incorrect, clear and obvious error (2:3). The referee was Andy Madley.
“The panel felt that a penalty should have been awarded for a holding action by Timber on Isak, 4:1. One panellist considered the short-lived holding to lack clear impact on the ability of Isak to progress. The majority also felt that VAR should have intervened to recommend an on-field review, 3:2, on the basis that it was a clear and obvious error. Two panellists considered that the subjectivity in assessing impact meant this did not meet the high threshold for VAR intervention.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 9, published by the Premier League on 11 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Match Round 10, published 18 November 2026
27 referee KMIs in Match Round 10, 78 per cent of on-field decisions deemed correct and the one VAR overturn supported; 223 KMIs across the season to date, 85 per cent of on-field decisions and 97 per cent of post-VAR outcomes deemed correct. The Premier League’s article and the full table (PDF).
- Everton v Coventry, Fri 6 Nov, 37:54. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by Tarkowski (EVE) on Yirenkyi (COV). On-field decision: incorrect, foul by Tarkowski (0:5); no VAR intervention, which the panel found incorrect, clear and obvious error (0:5). The referee was Stuart Attwell.
“Tarkowski had a hold of Yirenkyi’s hair as the Coventry attacker attempted to challenge for the ball. The panel unanimously felt that this was a punishable offence and that a penalty and a yellow card should have been awarded under the new guidelines for hair pulling actions this season. They also felt that VAR should have intervened, 0:5, as it was a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Everton v Coventry, Fri 6 Nov, 60:24. Goal awarded. Handball appeal against Barry (EVE). On-field decision: correct (2:3); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Stuart Attwell.
“This was a split decision, 2:3, with the majority feeling that on the balance of probability the ball did accidentally strike Barry’s hand before directly entering the goal. However, the non-VAR intervention was supported on the basis that the readily available footage did not provide conclusive evidence, which is the gateway for VAR intervention in factual matters.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Leeds v Spurs, Sat 7 Nov, 33:06. Sending off dismissal not given. Challenge by Bogle (LDS) on Tel (TOT). On-field decision: correct (3:2); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (3:2). The referee was John Brooks.
“This was a split decision with the majority supporting the referee’s on field call of no red card. The panel considered this to be a clear foul but the majority felt Bogle was looking to challenge with his right leg and his left leg came down on the back of Tel’s ankle without the speed, force or intensity to be serious foul play. They felt that the contact made was very clearly reckless, but below the threshold for a red card. Two Panellists felt that the challenge was sufficiently dangerous to merit a red card. The non-VAR intervention was also supported, 3:2, on the basis that the majority considered the challenge to be reckless, therefore not a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Arsenal v Hull, Sat 7 Nov, 41:02. Penalty not awarded. Havertz (ARS) in an offside position. On-field decision: incorrect (0:5); no VAR intervention, which the panel found incorrect (0:5). The referee was Farai Hallam.
“Although Havertz is clearly in an offside position, there is a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy before any potential offside offence by Havertz. Given the chronology of events, a penalty should have been awarded. The panel considered the VAR intervention was correct; however, the outcome after the on-field review was considered to be incorrect as a penalty should have been awarded.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Fulham v Newcastle, Sat 7 Nov, 32:22. Goal not awarded. Challenge by Wissa (NEW) on Castagne (FUL). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Rob Jones.
“The on field call to disallow the goal for a foul by Wissa on Castagne was unanimously supported.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brighton v Brentford, Sun 8 Nov, 20:30. Sending off, dismissal not given. Actions of Thiago (BRE) on Chema (BHA). On-field decision: correct (2:3); VAR overturned the on-field decision, which the panel found correct (3:2). The referee was Michael Oliver.
“The VAR intervention leading to a red card outcome for Thiago was supported, 3:2. Thiago’s forearm made forceful contact with the face of Chema. Two Panellists felt that the referee dealt with it adequately on field and that the referee’s call was not a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Brighton v Brentford, Sun 8 Nov, 39:53. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Lewis-Potter (BRE) on Vuskovic (BHA). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Michael Oliver.
“The referee’s call to award a penalty for a holding offence by Lewis-Potter on Vuskovic was supported, 4:1. One Panellist felt that the contact was principally driven by the attacker and exaggerated, therefore below the threshold for penalising holding actions.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Palace v Liverpool, Sun 8 Nov, 92:35. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Kerkez (LIV) on Osorio (CRY). On-field decision: incorrect, no foul by Kerkez (0:5); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (5:0). The referee was Tony Harrington.
“The panel unanimously felt that the referee’s call of a penalty for a challenge by Kerkez on Osorio was incorrect with the contact being inevitable given the jumping actions of both players. However, the non-intervention of VAR was supported on the basis it was not a clear and obvious error.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Ipswich v Bournemouth, Sun 8 Nov, 71:01. Penalty awarded. Challenge by Cook (BOU) on Ouattara (IPS). On-field decision: incorrect, no foul by Cook (1:4); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct, not a clear and obvious error (4:1). The referee was Simon Hooper.
“The panel felt that Ouattara made a clear step across Cook who didn’t make a challenge and therefore, felt that the referee’s decision to award a penalty was incorrect, 4:1. However, the non-VAR intervention was supported with it not being judged a clear and obvious error, also 4:1.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Ipswich v Bournemouth, Sun 8 Nov, 96:15. Second caution dismissal not given. Actions of Tavernier (BOU). On-field decision: incorrect (2:3); VAR not applicable. The referee was Simon Hooper.
“There was a clear, deliberate action by Tavernier to delay the restart and the panel felt that a second caution should have been issued in this instance, 3:2.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Sunderland v Chelsea, Sun 8 Nov, 22:04. Penalty not awarded. Challenge by O’Nien (SUN) on Palmer (CHE). On-field decision: correct (4:1); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (4:1). The referee was Jarred Gillett.
“There was clear contact made by O’Nien on Palmer which the panel felt should have been penalised with a free kick on the basis that contact was made outside the area, 4:1. One Panellist felt that the foul contact occurred inside the area and a penalty should have been awarded.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
- Man Utd v Villa, Sun 8 Nov, 95:45. Goal awarded. Challenge by Lammens (MUN) on Suzuki (AVL). On-field decision: correct (5:0); no VAR intervention, which the panel found correct (5:0). The referee was Chris Kavanagh.
“The panel felt that although Lammens turned away from the ball, the contact he made on Suzuki was not impactful and below the threshold for a foul, and the goal was correctly awarded.”Key Match Incidents panel, Match Round 10, published by the Premier League on 18 November 2026. Article, full table (PDF).
Common questions
What is the KMI panel?
The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents panel: five members, three former players or coaches, one Premier League representative and one from Pro Ref, the referees’ body formerly known as PGMOL. It reviews incidents chosen jointly by the Premier League and Pro Ref, votes on whether the on-field decision was correct and then whether the VAR outcome was correct, and its results are published about a week later (Premier League explainer on the KMI panel, 23 August 2026).
How do I read the votes?
Votes are written as the Premier League prints them. The first figure is the number of panellists who judged the decision correct and the second is the number who judged it incorrect. So “Incorrect (0:5)” means all five panellists found the decision incorrect, and “Correct, not a clear and obvious error (3:2)” means three of five supported the VAR for not intervening.
Is every incident the panel reviewed on this page?
No. This page carries the rows where the panel found a decision incorrect, where VAR overturned the on-field call, or where the vote was split, plus a few unanimous verdicts on widely searched incidents. The full table for each round, including every unanimous “correct” verdict, is in the Premier League’s PDF linked under each round.